WHAT MOVES SCORES
Rebuttals matter — when they bring evidence.
In an analysis of ICLR 2025, about 23% of reviews increased after the rebuttal and about 1% decreased. Evidence-backed clarifications were linked to increases; generic defenses were not.
FREE · NO SIGN-IN · ICLR 2027 SCORES SO FAR
ICLR 2027 uses a new rating scale (1, 2, 3, 4: 1 clear rejection, 2 weak rejection, 3 weak acceptance, 4 clear acceptance). Here is how the 23,759 ICLR 2027 submissions with reviews in our snapshot are scoring, from public OpenReview scores. Decisions come on Dec 16.
WHAT MOVES SCORES
In an analysis of ICLR 2025, about 23% of reviews increased after the rebuttal and about 1% decreased. Evidence-backed clarifications were linked to increases; generic defenses were not.
SCIME REBUTTAL ROOM
Import your OpenReview reviews, get a response plan per concern with matching manuscript edits, assign co-authors, stay within the character limit, and keep a camera-ready to-do list of what you promised.
Each ICLR 2027 submission with reviews counts once, at the mean of its official review ratings. The top 5%, 10%, 25% and 50% marks are the mean of the submission at that rank. This describes how reviews look this year, not a prediction for any paper: area chairs weigh review content, confidence and discussion, not just the mean.
During the ICLR 2027 review season, the score distribution is read from public OpenReview reviews at most every 6 hours. Only counts are kept: no titles, authors or review text. ICLR 2027 uses a new 1–4 rating scale that no earlier ICLR used, so there are no acceptance odds until decisions are out.